Learning Forum

[ventura]

? This post originally contained file attachments which have been removed in compliance with the updated Ansys Learning Forum Terms & Conditions

Hello, a customer reported this error. As you can see in the image the unfolded part (on the right) is ok, but in the drawing sheet is flipped, but the angle dimension still remains +90°. The right beahaviur is have the same results, even a flipped part with the opposite angle -90° is correct, but not a flipped unfolded part and a wrong angle, the employee who bends the part produce a wrong part and there's a waste of material for this error. This isn't the first bug report about this issue. It's very important have a reliable process in order to avoid to produce wrong part with waste of money and time. Please, solve this problem urgently!

[Devendra Badgujar]

Hello DrkAngl

Let me look into this and get back to you.

[ventura]

Thanks

[Roberto]

DrkAngl Hello 

What version of Spaceclaim are you using?

Regards

[ventura]

2021.2, but I seen the same problem with older version.

[Roberto]

Hello

the problem I had on 2 previous versions in this one no problem

Regards

[Devendra Badgujar]

Hello DrkAngl

I checked the model file and was able to reproduce some of it. The issue of flipped unfolded part in the drawing sheet is the known behavior but there seems to be no error on my end related to the angle.

I will raise a bug for the issue with the developers and will update you once I get any more information on this.

Regards.

[Devendra Badgujar]

Hello DrkAngl

Bug ( 559657 ) has been filed for this issue and will get back to you once I get an update.

Regards.

[ventura]

any news about fix?

[ventura]

I have again the same bug report. Wrong unfolded calculation. The unfolded shape should be mirrored. If I bend with this angle and this shape I'll get wrong part. If I use internal face I get the error, if I use external one not.

? This post originally contained file attachments which have been removed in compliance with the updated Ansys Learning Forum Terms & Conditions

[Devendra Badgujar]

Hi DrkAngl

The development team is working on it. I have not heard back from them on this.

I will check and let you know.

Regards.

[paul pladet]

Hello,

 

I also have a customer who reports a problem regarding the unfold :

[paul pladet]

Devendra Badgujar Could you please have a look at the problem above aswell?

[Devendra Badgujar]

Paesc 

This seems like the same issue as the one above where it is a drawing issue - UP/DOWN is relative to unfold plane and not related to drawing view's plane. 

I will check this case and will get back to you. 

[ventura]

Devendra Badgujar Any news about this problem? Now is solved with the upcoming version? Customers are angry to waste material due to software problem.

[Devendra Badgujar]

DrkAngl 

For this problem, it is a drawing issue - UP/DOWN is relative to unfold plane and not related to drawing view's plane.

We are looking into these features in the future releases in Discovery. We do not yet have a timeline for it. We will let you know when we learn more in the coming months. Thank you!

Regards.

[Roberto]

Devendra Badgujar This problem is important to solve

[paul pladet]

Hello,

Another issue with a customer. The incorrect part has already been produced and can now be tossed it in the iron scrap bin.