General Mechanical

General Mechanical

Topics related to Mechanical Enterprise, Motion, Additive Print and more.

Static Structural analysis system failed

    • fx213
      Subscriber

       Hello, 


      I would like to ask you a question on the analysis system of a static structural study that I tried to run on a cylindrical rubber sample but it failed.


      I have attached the respective file and I have also cited images of the Elastomer sample (Mooney Rivlin) [1] that I assigned from ANSYS Engineering data Hyper-elasic materials and the another one with all the steps of the analysis system.


      In the analysis settings, I inserted fixed support on the one cross-section (edge) of the cylinder and I applied displacement on the other cross-section (edge) of the cylinder in order to apply in that way axial compression stress on the model. I selected the result I wanted from the solution afterwards.


      Could you have a look and give me some feedback on where I have done wrong in the analysis steps or what I have omitted in that and it failed?


      Thank you in advance for your time.


      Kind regards, 


      FX


      Sample data to model as Mooney RivlinStatic structural analysis system failed

    • jj77
      Subscriber

      Could you please attach the model (it is not attached).


       


       

    • fx213
      Subscriber

      I think that I have to save the file in .wbpz type, whereas when I try to save the workbench project schematic, the only option is to save it in *.wbpj.


      Any suggestion on how I can attached the file in the discussion?


      Thank you


      FX

    • jj77
      Subscriber

      Go to file and archive, that will save it as .wbpz.

    • fx213
      Subscriber

      Thank you. 


      FX

    • jj77
      Subscriber

      I would fit a 5 parameter MR, as the one par. is not representing the exp. data/curve really well (very bad actually).


       


      The main reason of the converg. issue is the large displacement applied, which is much larger than the whole cylinder, so of course it cannot solve.


       


      Apply something reasonable and use the 5 parameter MR, and then it is OK.

    • peteroznewman
      Subscriber

      fx213,


      The cylinder is 11.18 mm tall, but the displacement is to compress it by 81 mm! That is clearly a mistake. I changed the displacement to -4 mm.


      Under Analysis settings, you must turn on Large Deflection


      Under Analysis settings, turn on Auto Time Stepping and set the Initial and Minimum Substeps to 100, the maximum can be 400.


      But that is not enough, it needs some more help in the form of Reduced Integration.  Under Geometry, set Element Control to Manual, Under the Body, set  Brick Integration Scheme to Reduced.


      I will post this now, even though with those changes, it stops converging at 0.18 mm. There are Keyop settings I have to go and look up, or perhaps a different element type. 


      You could make this go faster if you took a radial slice and used a 2D axisymmetric model.


       

Viewing 6 reply threads
  • The topic ‘Static Structural analysis system failed’ is closed to new replies.