Fluids

Fluids

Topics related to Fluent, CFX, Turbogrid and more.

Fluent Meshing Error

    • Aadya Goel
      Subscriber

      I'm getting this error with meshing. Please help!! 

      "Error: The surface meshing was not successful. Import the CAD outside the workflow and use Diagnostics to identify problematic faces." Where could I use diagnostics?

      Entire Console error:

      Reading "C:Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\TaskObject3.msh.h5" ...

      3D mesh

      nodes: 8575

      edges: 2047

      faces: 13146

      cells: 0

      reading 1 node zones

      reading 26 edge zones

      reading 12 face zones

      generating pointers...done.

      extracting boundary entities...

      8575 boundary nodes.

      13146 boundary faces.

      12 boundary face zones.

      done.

      analyzing boundary connectivity...done.

      Writing "C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\TaskObject3.msh.h5" ...

      writing 1 node zones

      writing 26 edge zones

      writing 12 face zones

      done.

      ---------------- The Global Max size was adjusted to 256

      processing size functions/scoped sizing to create Size Field...

       

      Writing "C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\Geom.sf"...

      Writing "C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\Geom.sf"...

      Done.

       

       

      Importing one mesh object per program-controlled and one zone per body ...

      C:\Program Files\ANSYS Inc\ANSYS Student\v231\commonfiles\CPython\3_7\winx64\Release\python\..\Ansys\TGrid\CADReaders.py started by aadya on Aadya winx64 on Sun Sep 10 16:48:55 2023

      using Python 3.7.13 (remotes/origin/3b89b4a151d5e27a7d119919e370e421549562b8-dirty:3b89b4a1, Sep 23 2) [MSC v.1920 64 bit (AMD64)]

       

      using Ansys.Meshing.FieldMesher build Nov 23 2022 18:41:14

       

      running ANSYS TGrid CADToTGridConverter ...

      setting up parameters ...

      setting up parameters done.

      running conversion ...

      converting 1 file(s) from Workbench to FLTG using output path 'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680/out169434473522680.tgf'

      converting file 'Geom.scdoc.pmdb' (1 of 1) from Workbench to FLTG using output path 'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680'

      importing data ...

      importing meshing model from PartMgr from file 'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\\Geom.scdoc.pmdb' ...

      setting enclosure and symmetry processing to False

      setting transfer named selections to True

      setting named selection prefixes to ''

      setting mixed import resolution type to 'SolidAndSurface'

      setting target application to 'FluentMeshing'

      initializing part manager from file ...

      processing assembly 'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\Geom.scdoc' with ID 1 and reference key '

       

       

       

       

       

      10000

      true

       

       

       

       

      10001

      true

       

       

       

       

      10002

      true

       

       

      '

      length unit = [m]

      processing part 'Enclosure' with ID 3

      processing part 'Geom' with ID 5

      processing part 'Geom' with ID 7

      processing named selection 'inlet'

      processing named selection 'outlet'

      processing named selection 'symmetry'

      processing named selection 'ground'

      processing named selection 'walls'

      processing named selection 'boi-farfield'

      processing named selection 'boi-nearfield'

      processing named selection 'front-wheel'

      processing named selection 'rear-wheel'

      processing named selection 'diffuser'

      processing named selection 'chassis'

      processing data ...

      loading size function background grid from file 'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\\Geom.sf' ...

      reading size function background grid file 'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\\Geom.sf' ...

      Read 373743 vertices

      initializing size function background grid done in 0.204 [s]

      Front could not be closed at e1283 (519.963531 2509.589793 2691.809740)

      Front could not be closed at e1356 (533.546826 2509.993730 2372.801629)

      Front could not be closed at be1611 (947.569623 2466.717905 2110.935642)

      Front could not be closed at be1888 (947.022487 2391.456644 1846.997524)

      Duplicate front Edge at (517.395498 2521.221025 2750.383845)

      tessellating 131 faces done in 117.694 [s]

      removing named collections of entities ...

      removing named collections of entities stopped, no named collections selected.

      analyzing feature edges ...

      detecting feature edges, feature angle = 40 [deg] ...

      Data information

      Meshing model

      Attributes:

      'LengthUnit': '[mm]'

      Entity summary:

      Collection: 11

      Component : 4

      Body : 3

      Shell : 3

      Face : 131

      Loop : 141

      Edge : 378

      Vertex : 257

      Surface : 131

      Curve : 378

      Tessellation summary:

      Face facets : 515144

      Edge segments: 17740

      Bounding box:

      (-801.7491455078125, 465.8739624023438, -1304.310546875) x (947.6422729492188, 2553.24609375, 7477.29150390625)

      Assembly component hierarchy:

      'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\Geom.scdoc'

      'Enclosure'

      'Geom'

      'Geom'

      NamedCollections:

      'inlet'

      'outlet'

      'symmetry'

      'ground'

      'walls'

      'boi-farfield'

      'boi-nearfield'

      'front-wheel'

      'rear-wheel'

      'diffuser'

      'chassis'

       

       

      exporting FLTG data to file 'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\out169434473522680.tgf' ...

      writing face-based mesh file 'C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\out169434473522680.tgf' ...

      ======== Exported Data ========

      Entity summary:

      Object : 3

      Object region: 15

      Zone : 44

       

      running conversion done.

      running ANSYS TGrid CADToTGridConverter done.

      ran ANSYS TGrid CADToTGridConverter in 119.123 [s]

      ======== Command Execution Log Manager ========

      Number of execution logs: 1

      MeshingModelCommandExecLog

      Label = 'ANSYS_MESH_FM_WARNING_ID_MESHINGMODEL_TESSELLATION_CREATION_ENTITIES_WHERE_CONFORMAL_TESSELLATION_FAILED'

      EntityIDs = (1141, 1144, 1174)

      Points = ()

       

       

       

      Reading "C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680/out169434473522680.tgf"...

      Reading "C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680/out169434473522680.tgf"...

      nodes: 271084

      edges: 12462

      faces: 515143

      cells: 0

      reading 271084 storage data (id 1, type 41, double precision binary).

      appending mesh...

      done.

      generating pointers...done.

      extracting boundary entities...

      279659 boundary nodes.

      528289 boundary faces.

      26 boundary face zones.

      done.

       

      Reading "C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\Geom.sf"...

      Reading "C:\Users\aadya\Desktop\Amrita Racing\cfd trial 2_files\dp0\Geom\DM\FM_Aadya_22680\Geom.sf"...

      Read 373743 vertices

      Warning: Deleting empty objects (geom-boi1)

       

      removed 116174 faces.

      Warning: Deleting empty objects (geom-boi2)

       

      removed 99784 faces.

      132 boundary nodes.

      0 faces removed.

       

      remeshing...

      Mesh topology corrupted at nodes bn265154 and bn266790.

      couldn't remove node at (947.148 2373.66 1811.92) from mesh46 boundary nodes.

      175 faces removed.

      51 faces are deleted1 boundary nodes.

      0 faces removed.

      201 boundary nodes.

      181 faces removed.

      20 faces are deleted7 boundary nodes.

      0 faces removed.

       

      Warning: Failed to remesh 7 area(s). Just mesh size adaptation was done for those area(s).

      Faces in those area(s) have been marked.

      220 faces are deleted---- Warning--- Repair (Patch) adjacent to zone symmetry was not successful

       

      remeshing...

      121 boundary nodes.

      54 faces removed.

      58 faces are deleted163 boundary nodes.

      89 faces removed.

      25 faces are deleted2 boundary nodes.

      0 faces removed.

       

      Warning: Failed to remesh 29 area(s). Just mesh size adaptation was done for those area(s).

      Faces in those area(s) have been marked.

      104 faces are deleted---- Warning--- Repair (Patch) adjacent to zone diffuser was not successful

      Deleted 1 faces with 3 free edges.

      Deleted 2 faces with 2 free edges.

      Deleted 0 faces with 3 free edges.

      Deleted 0 faces with 2 free edges.

      removed 9013 faces.

      removed 1959 faces.

      ---- Warning--- Free faces still exists in the model on ((diffuser chassis)) zones. If that is not expected, the surface meshing was not successful. Import the CAD outside the workflow and use Diagnostics to identify problematic faces

       

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256278-bn256069 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256278-bn256069 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256069-bn256278 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256069-bn256278 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256278-bn256069 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256278-bn256069 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256069-bn256278 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256069-bn256278 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn256069-bn256278 (544.096529 2501.345913 2322.370044).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn4263-bn4261 (721.352966 2384.141113 3426.622070).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn4261-bn4263 (721.352966 2384.141113 3426.622070).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn937-bn929 (795.690704 2516.571289 2873.401367).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn929-bn937 (795.690704 2516.571289 2873.401367).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn929-bn936 (795.371460 2516.207886 2873.483032).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Found overlapping faces sharing edge bn936-bn929 (795.371460 2516.207886 2873.483032).

      Warning:

      The regions may not be computed correctly.

      Error: The surface meshing was not successful. Import the CAD outside the workflow and use Diagnostics to identify problematic faces

      Error Object: #f

    • Keyur Kanade
      Ansys Employee
       
       
      Please check geometry in SpaceClaim. 
      Select geometry in structure tree --> Use right click --> Select Check Geometry. (Or Tools - Fault Detection in DM)
      The geometry should be error free to proceed. 
      If geometry has any errors, please modify/recreate geometry at those places. 
       
      Once geometry is OK, please do share topology. You can find share topology information at following link: 
       
       
      Share topology in important operation before going to Fluent Meshing. If it is failing at some places, it may give errors in Fluent Meshing about surface intersection. 
       
      Now if share topology is successful and still you are getting errors in Fluent Meshing, then it could be due to insufficient sizing. Please make sure that you have applied correct sizing to capture different parts. You can find more information about sizing at following link. 
       
       

      You can also check following videos

       

      DM Share topology:

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IO4ZtwZdD2I

      This video demonstrates how to use Shared Topology in DesignModeler 16.x to connect two or more bodies together to form a single, continuous body while preserving interfaces between them.

       

      Fluent Meshing Watertight Workflow:

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBxbYRVoRLo

      This video provides a walk-through of the Watertight Geometry Guided Meshing Workflow for Fluent. The workflow provides a way to import a watertight or \"clean\" CAD geometry, add optional local sizing, create a surface mesh, create fluid/solid regions, and generate a complete volume mesh in a step-by-step interface.
       

      Regards,

      Keyur

      How to access Ansys Online Help Document

      Guidelines on the Student Community

      Fluids Engineering Courses | Ansys Innovation Courses

       

       

    • Aadya Goel
      Subscriber

       

      It asks for this: in the link https://ansyshelp.ansys.com/account/secured?returnurl=/Views/Secured/corp/v221/en/spaceclaim/Discovery/user_manual/st_sharetopology.html?q=share%20topology 

       

      I have a student account – how should I get this? 

      Thank you 

       

    • Aadya Goel
      Subscriber

      Additionally, will the mesh be accepted if there are bodies that are not connected to each other? In this file, the wheels are not connected with the body of the car. 

    • Keyur Kanade
      Ansys Employee

      For non connected bodies, you can use non conformal interface in Fluent. 

      These are links in the help manual. 

      Please check links below my signature. 

      Regards,

      Keyur

      How to access Ansys Online Help Document

      Guidelines on the Student Community

      Fluids Engineering Courses | Ansys Innovation Courses

       

      • Aadya Goel
        Subscriber

        Is that why the original error is coming? Because the bodies are not connected? 

    • Keyur Kanade
      Ansys Employee

      The error is very generic. It may be due to bad geometry. Please check geometry in SpaceClaim. 
      Select geometry in structure tree --> Use right click --> Select Check Geometry. (Or Tools - Fault Detection in DM)
      The geometry should be error free to proceed. 
      If geometry has any errors, please modify/recreate geometry at those places. 

      The error may be due to intersecting bodies as well. Pelase check Interference tool in Fluent Meshing. 

      The error may be due to wrong sizing in Fluent Meshing. Please make sure that you provide correct sizing at various places. 

      Please go through help manual for more details 

      Regards,

      Keyur

      How to access Ansys Online Help Document

      Guidelines on the Student Community

      Fluids Engineering Courses | Ansys Innovation Courses

       

Viewing 5 reply threads
  • The topic ‘Fluent Meshing Error’ is closed to new replies.