General Mechanical

General Mechanical

Topics related to Mechanical Enterprise, Motion, Additive Print and more.

Does Bisection means the solution is wrong in a non-linear analysis ?

    • sid10mahesh
      Subscriber

      Can anyone explain me what is the idea behind the error bisection in ansys? I did a hyper-elastic material simulation and I got a bisection in the Force convergence plot. But my solution got converged at the very end. Does this mean my simulation is wrong and will it affect my solution accuracy at any level ? Any idea will be greatly appreciated !

      Kindly help @peteroznewman @raul.raghav

      Thanks in advance!

    • Erik Kostson
      Ansys Employee


      Bisection similar to load scaling, are reducing the load applied, in order to help the solver to obtain convergence when it is struggling with the nonlinear solution due to to high load applied.
      This means that a smaller load increment needed to be applied to achieve convergence. So see it as a way of getting convergence. Other Ways to help the solver obtain a converged solution are displacement scaling, arc length, and others.

      So of course if it is converged then the solution is fine, and that is what matters (to have a converged solution), and since yours did it should be fine (of course if the solution is correct and represents reality, capturing the physics correctly, that is another question, which you would need to verify say against hand calcs. or validate against tests, so all FEA results should be checked like that). The bisection was just used to obtain a converged solution when it was difficult for the solver to do so.

      I would suggest to read through the manual (search for bisection), this forum and the web for more info.

      All the best

      Erik

    • sid10mahesh
      Subscriber
      Thank you Erik ! That was a very great info. Thank you so much for the help :)
Viewing 2 reply threads
  • The topic ‘Does Bisection means the solution is wrong in a non-linear analysis ?’ is closed to new replies.