Learning Forum

[Roberto]

Hi About 2 years ago I think I reported this bug that was fixed by the 2019 version, now the same BUG reappears in the 2020 versions. When I go to develop a sheet metal file and place it on the table it is oriented 180 degrees with respect to the other Best Regards

? This post originally contained file attachments which have been removed in compliance with the updated Ansys Learning Forum Terms & Conditions

[Charudatta Bandgar]

Hello Robert ,

 

Even I have experienced the issue. I think the drawing is aligned with the positive XY axis.  

I am not sure if it is intended behaviour, I will get in touch with the experts/developers, and will let you know.

Do you recall the bug ID filed 2 years back (or any mail thread)? (I will try to find it as well).

Regards.

[Roberto]

Hello Charudatta Bandgar I am attaching the post where I wrote, in private I can send you the email I sent to support some time ago /forum/t/y79nvb/sheet-metal Best Regards

[Roberto]

Hello Charudatta Bandgar

I sent you the email

Best Regards

[Roberto]

Charudatta Bandgar Hello

were you able to read the email in private?

Best Regars

[Charudatta Bandgar]

Yes, Robert 

I am getting information what the issue is, and trying to get the older bug ID, otherwise I will create a bug ticket today.

Regards.

[Roberto]

Charudatta Bandgar Have you tried to contact Brian Bueno too?

Best Regards

[Charudatta Bandgar]

Yes, Robert 

[Charudatta Bandgar]

Hello Robert ,

Sorry for the delayed response, I am in conversations with the developers, and I will get the roots of this issue. Can you please send the file you worked on?

Regards.

[Roberto]

Hello Charudatta Bandgar The problem occurs in all created files , it is not a problem that only occurs on some specific files I can send you a file Best Regards  

? This post originally contained file attachments which have been removed in compliance with the updated Ansys Learning Forum Terms & Conditions

[Charudatta Bandgar]

Hello Robert , Please look into the file attached, and let me know if I did it correctly. I misunderstood the issue initially, and I am not seeing the issue you have faced. Please correct me if I did not understand it right. Regards.

? This post originally contained file attachments which have been removed in compliance with the updated Ansys Learning Forum Terms & Conditions

[Roberto]

Hello Charudatta Bandgar The problem occurs when you click on the back face. Sorry I forgot to say   Best Regards

? This post originally contained file attachments which have been removed in compliance with the updated Ansys Learning Forum Terms & Conditions

[Charudatta Bandgar]

Hello Robert ,

I am experiencing similar behaviour in 2019R3, 2020R1 and 2020R2.5.

 Regards

[Roberto]

Hello Charudatta Bandgar You’re right, the old bug was very similar and so I got confused ( I’ll attach you the video of the old bug that was fixed and is still fixed). The video called test as you can see , if I open all 3 windows when I go to explain it works correctly , while if I do it in the way we have done so far it is not rotated correctly in the Drawing formt. So I think we found a new mistake. Let me know what you think Best Regards

? This post originally contained file attachments which have been removed in compliance with the updated Ansys Learning Forum Terms & Conditions

[Roberto]

Charudatta Bandgar  Hello

We are waiting for an answer, are the developers fixing this bug?

Best Regards

[Roberto]

The problem occurs when the unfolded is open and I put it on the drawing format

[Roberto]

Charudatta Bandgar .

Let me know if the remaining problem is clear

Best Regards

[Charudatta Bandgar]

Yes, Robert .

I have understood the query. To summarize what I have conveyed to the experts and  awaiting a response from the experts: 

• If a sheet metal component is flattened and drawing is created (with bottom and top face being considered while flattening), the drawing generated does not change the orientation. (when opened in two screens as shown in the video (attached video mentioned in the following comment: sheet_metal)

The problem occurs when you click on the back face.
Sorry I forgot to say

•  If the same sheet metal is flattened, and all the windows are opened in three different screens, the behaviour is accurate (that is, the face selection while flattening changes the orientation of drawing correctly.) video attached named test_now

In all the cases the orientation is accurate, and the older bug is addressed.

Please let me know, if I have understood and conveyed correctly.

Regards.

[Roberto]

Charudatta Bandgar Hello

You’re perfect It’s just like that 

[Roberto]

Hello Charudatta Bandgar

 

Is it possible to have a problem identification code?

 

Best Regard

[Roberto]

Charudatta Bandgar do you have any news from the technical developers?

Best Regards

[of]

Charudatta Bandgar

Has this problem been identified as a BUG?

Can you give us an identification number?

Best Regards

[Charudatta Bandgar]

Hello omar Roberto

The bug ID is 401468, I have not heard from the developers regarding it much.

Regards.

[Roberto]

Charudatta Bandgar Hello 

Hope it is correct in the next version

Best Regards

[cbur]

Hello, Have you got any feedback on fixing this BUG or an effective workaround? In my case the unfold is right but the import in the drawing is wrong... (if you choose to unfold from the lower interior surface). regards

[Roberto]

Hello charlie

I am a colleague of Omar, we have not received a reply from ANSYS anymore.

Do you have any news? Charudatta Bandgar

Regards