Auto Skin Keep Faces from Solid Body

[jmoore]

I'm trying to use Auto Skin selecting the original solid body to keep the facets that match the faces of the origianl solid body following the instructions here: Creating the CAD Geometry

However, when I run the tool, it doesn't match the faces and I'm left with a geometry like this: 

Any suggestions on how to make this behave more like the example?

[Atharv Joshi]

Hi Jmoore, 

If you are using Autoskin the result should be patch body (CAD) and not a faceted body. 
Do you see any error message after the Auto-skin operation? The image seems like a result of ShrinkWrap Tool.

Regards
Atharv

[jdmoore2]

Hi Atharv,

You are correct. I submitted the wrong picture. Here is a better example:

I would expect it to look more like this simplified example part I was able to get working: