We’re putting the final touches on our new badges platform. Badge issuance remains temporarily paused, but all completions are being recorded and will be fulfilled once the platform is live. Thank you for your patience.

Ansys Learning Forum Forums Discuss Simulation Fluids Multiphase VOF simulation of a rotating capillary tube Reply To: Multiphase VOF simulation of a rotating capillary tube

Livio Michele Moesch
Subscriber

I am replying late as the forum was down for maintenance a long time. I downloaded 24R1 and tried running the same case, but that didn't lead to substantial changes. The timestep sizes that were diverging before are still diverging, even if a little later with actually slightly different contours, the stable ones from before lead to basically identical results.

Timestep 3e-5s, Velocity limited to 50m/s, Wall rotating at 1 rad/s

Timestep 1e-5s, Velocity limited to 50m/s, Wall rotating at 1 rad/s

 

As the densities of the two phases are very different and hence the problem that arose was excactly what Fluent describes as critical for stability, I tried pushing the velocity limiting even further (to 1m/s, with 3e-5s as timestep), as 1rad/s with a radius of 1mm means speeds in the orders of magnitude around 0.01m/s. Unfortunately this lead to unphysical results, something known in the Fluent Guides. It's also worth noting that I cannot replicate this unphysical contour (which is present throughout the whole calculation) using smaller timesteps (they would again lead to a fully "flat surface", looking exactly as if there was no rotation imposed at all). 

Increasing the rotational speeds to 50rad/s constant or applying a 50rad/s triangular peak don't change the profile when simulating with the timestep size 1e-5s, and with bigger timesteps I get the same divergence as before. The backflow in on the open boundary changes a little, indicating to me that Fluent is not disregarding the change in rotational speed; but as to what I expect from the solution and want to prove I am not able to get the software to perform results that should be phyiscal in my opinion.

Timestep 1e-5s, Velocity limited to 50m/s, Wall rotating at 50 rad/s

 

I'd be glad about final thoughts on where these problems could arise from and what I could be doing wrong.