Learning Forum

[deepesh.p.gurdasani]

An error comes like 'Element (element number) has a radius/thickness ratio of (some no.). This violates assemption of shell element.' I tried changing the mesh but still same error pops up and the solution stops.

Can anyone guide how to get this error removed/resolved ? 

Thanks in advance

[Aniket]

Can you repost your query again? It seems blank currently.

-Aniket

Forum Rules & Guidelines

[deepesh.p.gurdasani]

I have edited the query again and also replying it here:

An error comes like 'Element (element number) has a radius/thickness ratio of (some no.). This violates assemption of shell element.' I tried changing the mesh but still same error pops up and the solution stops.

Can anyone guide how to get this error removed/resolved ? 

Thanks in advance

[Ashish Khemka]

Hi,

Please try using a different mesh size.

Also, please see if the following link helps: 

Why does Mechanical APDL give the error, " Element xxxx has a radius/thickness ratio of xxxxxx. This violates assumption of shell element" even after turning off shape checking SHPP, OFF? - Ansys Knowledge

Regards,

Ashish Khemka

[deepesh.p.gurdasani]

Tried using different mesh size but still the same error.

[Aniket]

 

To expand on what Gary and Ashish have said:

The issue is happening due to the Warping of the shell elements and coming due to inadequately defined mesh, there are multiple ways to overcome this

 

1. Use linear mesh
2. Refine the mesh in the region where reported warping is high
3. Use a SOLVE,,,,,NOCHECK command to ignore the error (last resort)

 

To know about the issue please refer to this link
https://ansyshelp.ansys.com/account/Secured?returnurl=/Views/Secured/corp/v241/en/ans_elem/Hlp_E_ShellElements.html%23d0e14315

https://ansyshelp.ansys.com/account/secured?returnurl=/Views/Secured/corp/v241/en/ans_thry/thy_et7.html%23eltwarping

-Aniket

Forum Rules & Guidelines

 

 

[Gary_S]

Hi Deepesh

 Try adjusting the Thickness in the Surface body details. 
 Also, can you show an image of your model?