Errors – Reinforced Concrete Beam

- July 19, 2018 at 3:23 pm
  
  Joseph Lim
  Subscriber
  
  Dear all,
  
  Attached are two errors that I encounter when modelling the beam using the Finite Element Method (FEM). May I ask for some suggestions and help with those problems?
  
  The first error is regarding the converge on a solution for the nonlinear problem. May I know why will this happen and how to solve it?
  
  The second error is regarding an internal solution magnitude limit was exceeded. Is that mean that the load applied to the beam was too large or exceed the ultimate load?
  
  Thank you in advance.
  
  Regards,
  
  Joseph
- July 19, 2018 at 3:44 pm
  Sandeep Medikonda
  Ansys Employee
  Hi Joseph,
  
  In finite element analyses, all the components are expected to be fully constrained to ensure that the applied forces and the internal forces will balance each other out. The reaction force always follows stiffness and constraints, if there is neither of them to resist an applied force, it results in rigid body motion.
  
  When a model is not fully constrained in Static structural analysis, the solver throws out pivoting error, or errors related to a certain degree of freedom (DOF) exceeding limits. Four ways for identifying the unconstrained body are:
  
  1. If the message appears under the WB messages, right click on the message > Go to Object will take you to the part under Geometry Tree.
  
  2. Identify the node based on the node number provided in the error message. In case the node number is not available in the mesh, it must be an internal node created by Mechanical for features such as remote points, or bolt pretension.
  
  3. Perform a modal analysis on the assembly to identify if there are any 0 Hz (or near zero) modes. If such modes are identified, plot the mode shapes for those modes to identify which parts are free floating.
  
  4. Turn on the Newton-Raphson residuals under Solution information prior to running the model and check the contours for residuals, typically when a part is not constrained, the residuals are distributed all over the problematic part.
  
  Possible Solutions:
  - Once you identify the part, check how is the part supposed to be held in place in the actual physical application.
  - If the internal forces are expected to be self-balancing due to symmetry (e.g., free thermal expansion of parts), then use weak springs (turn it ON under Analysis Settings) or inertial relief for linear models (small deformation, linear materials, linear contacts).
  In case the part is to be held in place by contacts:
  
  Linear contacts (bonded and no separation):
  - make sure that there are no initial gaps or penetrations between the parts.
  - If there are any, manually define pinball radius so that it is larger than the gap/penetration. Also, use MPC formulation if there are no other MPC based constraints in the vicinity.
  - Mesh in the contact region is fine enough.
  Nonlinear contacts (frictionless, frictional and rough):
  - Change the contact type to Bonded to see if that fixes the issue. If it does, proceed to the following steps. If not, check if the steps listed under linear contacts resolve the issue. If yes, then proceed with the following steps. • If gap is negligibly small, consider using the Interface Treatment Option "Adjust to Touch" to close the gap.
  - Use a small amount of friction so that part will not slide away during loading.
  - In case of force or pressure loading, use smaller initial timestep, increase a pinball radius.
  - If the issue persists, define contact stabilization damping (use a small value such as 5e-2).
  - Mesh in the contact region is fine enough.
  - In case of internal nodes such a bolt pretension, make sure that there is no conflicting constraint equation based definition (e.g., scoped surface sharing bolt pretension and symmetry conditions).
- April 30, 2020 at 7:08 am
  
  sruthyvs
  Subscriber
  
  I an a newbie to ansys. I need to design a soil pile continuum model in ansys 19.2.I am using a licensed software. I have created a concrete circular single end bearing pile of 500mm Dia and 12m depth in a soil block of 10*10*12 having 5 soil layers of sand and clay..... Including 6 main rebars... 17 top stirrups and... 11 bottom stirrups. I am doing this work to get this settlement analysis in Mohr coulumb model. I found issue in dealing with connections and contacts. I have given bonded connection for steel to concrete, steel rft with stirrups, bw soil layer and frictional contact with coefficient 0.2 for concrete to soil connections. But there occurred problems of overlapping and penetration.... I have just created a default mesh having 0.67m element size with 204484 elements and 981245 nodes with 40 bodies of total... A remote force of - 90Ton but m not getting the total and directional deformation... Saying an unknown error.... And CPU time elapsed..... I am using an i7 lap with 16gb ram and graphics card.... Please help me out to sort out my problem.... I jzt need information on assigning contacts and mesh. I have created contact tool... But some of the contacts are seen inactive and one contact is bonded and closed but has a large amount of penetration and gap? I don't know what it means and how can I solve this.... I just wanna find the soil settlement ie deformation of soil and pile as a whole....
  
  sir could you plz help me to sort out my errors while doing the ansys project.
  
  ANSYS Mechanical Enterprise
  
  *
  *
  |                                                                  |
  |   W E L C O M E   T O   T H E   A N S Y S (R) P R O G R A M     |
  |                                                                  |
  *
  *
  
  ***************************************************************
  *            ANSYS Release 19.2     LEGAL NOTICES             *
  ***************************************************************
  *                                                             *
  * Copyright 1971-2018 ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.       *
  * Unauthorized use, distribution or duplication is            *
  * prohibited.                                                 *
  *                                                             *
  * Ansys is a registered trademark of ANSYS, Inc. or its       *
  * subsidiaries in the United States or other countries.       *
  * See the ANSYS, Inc. online documentation or the ANSYS, Inc. *
  * documentation CD or online help for the complete Legal      *
  * Notice.                                                     *
  *                                                             *
  ***************************************************************
  *                                                             *
  * THIS ANSYS SOFTWARE PRODUCT AND PROGRAM DOCUMENTATION       *
  * INCLUDE TRADE SECRETS AND CONFIDENTIAL AND PROPRIETARY      *
  * PRODUCTS OF ANSYS, INC., ITS SUBSIDIARIES, OR LICENSORS.    *
  * The software products and documentation are furnished by    *
  * ANSYS, Inc. or its subsidiaries under a software license    *
  * agreement that contains provisions concerning               *
  * non-disclosure, copying, length and nature of use,          *
  * compliance with exporting laws, warranties, disclaimers,    *
  * limitations of liability, and remedies, and other           *
  * provisions. The software products and documentation may be *
  * used, disclosed, transferred, or copied only in accordance *
  * with the terms and conditions of that software license      *
  * agreement.                                                  *
  *                                                             *
  * ANSYS, Inc. is a UL registered                              *
  * ISO 9001:2008 company.                                      *
  *                                                             *
  ***************************************************************
  *                                                             *
  * This product is subject to U.S. laws governing export and   *
  * re-export.                                                  *
  *                                                             *
  * For U.S. Government users, except as specifically granted   *
  * by the ANSYS, Inc. software license agreement, the use,     *
  * duplication, or disclosure by the United States Government *
  * is subject to restrictions stated in the ANSYS, Inc.        *
  * software license agreement and FAR 12.212 (for non-DOD      *
  * licenses).                                                  *
  *                                                             *
  ***************************************************************
  
  Release 19.2
  
  Point Releases and Patches installed:
  
  ANSYS, Inc. Products Release 19.2
  SpaceClaim Release 19.2
  AIM Release 19.2
  Autodyn Release 19.2
  LS-DYNA Release 19.2
  CFD-Post only Release 19.2
  CFX (includes CFD-Post) Release 19.2
  Chemkin Release 19.2
  EnSight Release 19.2
  FENSAP-ICE Release 19.2
  Fluent (includes CFD-Post) Release 19.2
  Forte Release 19.2
  Polyflow (includes CFD-Post) Release 19.2
  TurboGrid Release 19.2
  ICEM CFD Release 19.2
  Aqwa Release 19.2
  Customization Files for User Programmable Features Release 19.2
  Mechanical Products Release 19.2
  Icepak (includes CFD-Post) Release 19.2
  Remote Solve Manager Standalone Services Release 19.2
  Viewer Release 19.2
  ACIS Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  AutoCAD Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  Catia, Version 4 Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  Catia, Version 5 Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  Catia, Version 6 Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  Creo Elements/Direct Modeling Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  Creo Parametric Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  Inventor Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  JTOpen Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  NX Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  Parasolid Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  Solid Edge Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  SOLIDWORKS Geometry Interface Release 19.2
  ANSYS, Inc. License Manager Release 19.2
  
            ***** ANSYS COMMAND LINE ARGUMENTS *****
  BATCH MODE REQUESTED (-b)    = NOLIST
  INPUT FILE COPY MODE (-c)    = COPY
  DISTRIBUTED MEMORY PARALLEL REQUESTED
         2 PARALLEL PROCESSES REQUESTED WITH SINGLE THREAD PER PROCESS
      TOTAL OF     2 CORES REQUESTED
  MPI OPTION                   = INTELMPI
  INPUT FILE NAME              = F:SDWORKSPACEMINI-PROJECT ANSYS WORKANSYS WORK (05-04-2020)SOIL-PILE MODEL TRIAL 1SOIL MODEL WITH MANUAL CONTACTS 30-04-2020600mm DIAMETER_ProjectScratchScrF9B3dummy.dat
  OUTPUT FILE NAME             = F:SDWORKSPACEMINI-PROJECT ANSYS WORKANSYS WORK (05-04-2020)SOIL-PILE MODEL TRIAL 1SOIL MODEL WITH MANUAL CONTACTS 30-04-2020600mm DIAMETER_ProjectScratchScrF9B3solve.out
  START-UP FILE MODE           = NOREAD
  STOP FILE MODE               = NOREAD
  
  RELEASE= Release 19.2         BUILD= 19.2      UP20180808   VERSION=WINDOWS x64
  CURRENT JOBNAME=file0 112:46 APR 30, 2020 CP=      0.172
  
  PARAMETER _DS_PROGRESS =     999.0000000
  
  /INPUT FILE= ds.dat LINE=       0
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =       0.297   TIME= 112:46
  The /CONFIG,NOELDB command is not valid in a Distributed ANSYS
  solution. Command is ignored.
  
  *GET _WALLSTRT FROM ACTI ITEM=TIME WALL VALUE= 11.5461111
  
  TITLE=
  TRIAL-1(600mm dia)--Static Structural (B5)
  
  SET PARAMETER DIMENSIONS ON _WB_PROJECTSCRATCH_DIR
  TYPE=STRI DIMENSIONS=      248        1        1
  
  PARAMETER _WB_PROJECTSCRATCH_DIR(1) = F:SDWORKSPACEMINI-PROJECT ANSYS WORKANSYS WORK (05-04-2020)SOIL-PILE MODEL TRIAL 1SOIL MODEL WITH MANUAL CONTACTS 30-04-2020600mm DIAMETER_ProjectScratchScrF9B3
  
  SET PARAMETER DIMENSIONS ON _WB_SOLVERFILES_DIR
  TYPE=STRI DIMENSIONS=      248        1        1
  
  PARAMETER _WB_SOLVERFILES_DIR(1) = F:SDWORKSPACEMINI-PROJECT ANSYS WORKANSYS WORK (05-04-2020)SOIL-PILE MODEL TRIAL 1SOIL MODEL WITH MANUAL CONTACTS 30-04-2020600mm DIAMETERTRIAL-1(600mm dia)_filesdp0SYS-1MECH
  
  SET PARAMETER DIMENSIONS ON _WB_USERFILES_DIR
  TYPE=STRI DIMENSIONS=      248        1        1
  
  PARAMETER _WB_USERFILES_DIR(1) = F:SDWORKSPACEMINI-PROJECT ANSYS WORKANSYS WORK (05-04-2020)SOIL-PILE MODEL TRIAL 1SOIL MODEL WITH MANUAL CONTACTS 30-04-2020600mm DIAMETERTRIAL-1(600mm dia)_filesuser_files
  --- Data in consistent MKS units. See Solving Units in the help system for more
  
  MKS UNITS SPECIFIED FOR INTERNAL
  LENGTH        (l) = METER (M)
  MASS          (M) = KILOGRAM (KG)
  TIME          (t) = SECOND (SEC)
  TEMPERATURE   (T) = CELSIUS (C)
  TOFFSET            = 273.0
  CHARGE        (Q) = COULOMB
  FORCE         (f) = NEWTON (N) (KG-M/SEC2)
  HEAT               = JOULE (N-M)
  
  PRESSURE           = PASCAL (NEWTON/M**2)
  ENERGY        (W) = JOULE (N-M)
  POWER         (P) = WATT (N-M/SEC)
  CURRENT       (i) = AMPERE (COULOMBS/SEC)
  CAPACITANCE   (C) = FARAD
  INDUCTANCE    (L) = HENRY
  MAGNETIC FLUX      = WEBER
  RESISTANCE    (R) = OHM
  ELECTRIC POTENTIAL = VOLT
  
  INPUT UNITS ARE ALSO SET TO MKS
  
  *** ANSYS - ENGINEERING ANALYSIS SYSTEM RELEASE Release 19.2     19.2     ***
  DISTRIBUTED ANSYS Mechanical Enterprise
  
  00000000 VERSION=WINDOWS x64   112:46 APR 30, 2020 CP=      0.297
  
  TRIAL-1(600mm dia)--Static Structural (B5)
  
            ***** ANSYS ANALYSIS DEFINITION (PREP7) *****
  *********** Nodes for the whole assembly ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 1 "MEDIUM SAND 2" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 2 "MEDIUM SAND 1" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 3 "SILTY SANDY CLAY 3" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 4 "SILTY SANDY CLAY 2" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 5 "SILTY SANDY CLAY 1" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 6 "CONCRETE-PILE" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 7 "TOP STIRRUPS 1" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 8 "TOP STIRRUPS 2" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 9 "TOP STIRRUPS 3" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 10 "TOP STIRRUPS 4" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 11 "TOP STIRRUPS 5" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 12 "TOP STIRRUPS 6" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 13 "TOP STIRRUPS 7" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 14 "TOP STIRRUPS 8" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 15 "TOP STIRRUPS 9" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 16 "TOP STIRRUPS 10" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 17 "TOP STIRRUPS 11" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 18 "TOP STIRRUPS 12" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 19 "TOP STIRRUPS 13" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 20 "TOP STIRRUPS 14" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 21 "TOP STIRRUPS 15" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 22 "TOP STIRRUPS 16" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 23 "TOP STIRRUPS 17" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 24 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 1" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 25 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 2" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 26 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 3" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 27 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 4" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 28 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 5" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 29 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 6" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 30 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 7" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 31 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 8" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 32 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 9" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 33 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 10" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 34 "BOTTOM STIRRUPS 11" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 35 "MAIN LONG REBARS 1" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 36 "MAIN LONG REBARS 2" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 37 "MAIN LONG REBARS 3" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 38 "MAIN LONG REBARS 4" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 39 "MAIN LONG REBARS 5" ***********
  *********** Elements for Body 40 "MAIN LONG REBARS 6" ***********
  *********** Send User Defined Coordinate System(s) ***********
  *********** Set Reference Temperature ***********
  *********** Send Materials ***********
  *********** Create Contact "Frictional - CONCRETE-PILE To Multiple" ***********
               Real Constant Set For Above Contact Is 42 & 41
  *********** Create Contact "Bonded - MEDIUM SAND 2 To MEDIUM SAND 1" *********
               Real Constant Set For Above Contact Is 44 & 43
  *********** Create Contact "Bonded - MEDIUM SAND 1 To SILTY SANDY CLAY 3" *****
               Real Constant Set For Above Contact Is 46 & 45
  *********** Create Contact "Bonded - SILTY SANDY CLAY 3 To SILTY SANDY CLAY 2"
               Real Constant Set For Above Contact Is 48 & 47
  *********** Create Contact "Bonded - SILTY SANDY CLAY 2 To SILTY SANDY CLAY 1"
               Real Constant Set For Above Contact Is 50 & 49
  *********** Create Contact "Bonded - CONCRETE-PILE To Multiple" ***********
               Real Constant Set For Above Contact Is 52 & 51
  *********** Create Contact "Bonded - Multiple To Multiple" ***********
               Real Constant Set For Above Contact Is 54 & 53
  *********** Fixed Supports ***********
  *********** Define Pressure Using Surface Effect Elements ***********
  
  ***** ROUTINE COMPLETED ***** CP =         6.219
  
  --- Number of total nodes = 975357
  --- Number of contact elements = 547031
  --- Number of spring elements = 0
  --- Number of bearing elements = 0
  --- Number of solid elements = 202818
  --- Number of condensed parts = 0
  --- Number of total elements = 749849
  
  *GET _WALLBSOL FROM ACTI ITEM=TIME WALL VALUE= 11.5472222
  ****************************************************************************
  *************************    SOLUTION       ********************************
  ****************************************************************************
  
  ***** ANSYS SOLUTION ROUTINE *****
  
  PERFORM A STATIC ANALYSIS
  THIS WILL BE A NEW ANALYSIS
  
  LARGE DEFORMATION ANALYSIS
  
  USE SPARSE MATRIX DIRECT SOLVER
  
  CONTACT INFORMATION PRINTOUT LEVEL       1
  
  DO NOT COMBINE ELEMENT MATRIX FILES (.emat) AFTER DISTRIBUTED PARALLEL SOLUTION
  
  DO NOT COMBINE ELEMENT SAVE DATA FILES (.esav) AFTER DISTRIBUTED PARALLEL SOLUTION
  
  NLDIAG: Nonlinear diagnostics CONT option is set to ON.
           Writing frequency : each ITERATION.
  
  DEFINE RESTART CONTROL FOR LOADSTEP LAST
  AT FREQUENCY OF LAST AND NUMBER FOR OVERWRITE IS    0
  
  DELETE RESTART FILES OF ENDSTEP
  ****************************************************
  ******************* SOLVE FOR LS 1 OF 1 ****************
  
  SELECT       FOR ITEM=TYPE COMPONENT=
  IN RANGE        55 TO         55 STEP          1
  
          147 ELEMENTS (OF     749849 DEFINED) SELECTED BY ESEL COMMAND.
  
  SELECT      ALL NODES HAVING ANY ELEMENT IN ELEMENT SET.
  
          488 NODES (OF     975357 DEFINED) SELECTED FROM
        147 SELECTED ELEMENTS BY NSLE COMMAND.
  
  GENERATE SURFACE LOAD PRES ON SURFACE DEFINED BY ALL SELECTED NODES
  VALUES= 346840.000      0.00000000
  
  NUMBER OF PRES ELEMENT FACE LOADS STORED =        147
  
  ALL SELECT   FOR ITEM=NODE COMPONENT=
  IN RANGE         1 TO     975357 STEP          1
  
       975357 NODES (OF     975357 DEFINED) SELECTED BY NSEL COMMAND.
  
  ALL SELECT   FOR ITEM=ELEM COMPONENT=
  IN RANGE         1 TO     749849 STEP          1
  
       749849 ELEMENTS (OF     749849 DEFINED) SELECTED BY ESEL COMMAND.
  
  ALL SELECT   FOR ITEM=ELEM COMPONENT=
  IN RANGE         1 TO     749849 STEP          1
  
       749849 ELEMENTS (OF     749849 DEFINED) SELECTED BY ESEL COMMAND.
  
  PRINTOUT RESUMED BY /GOP
  
  USE AUTOMATIC TIME STEPPING THIS LOAD STEP
  
  USE       1 SUBSTEPS INITIALLY THIS LOAD STEP FOR ALL DEGREES OF FREEDOM
  FOR AUTOMATIC TIME STEPPING:
     USE     10 SUBSTEPS AS A MAXIMUM
     USE      1 SUBSTEPS AS A MINIMUM
  
  TIME= 1.0000
  
  ERASE THE CURRENT DATABASE OUTPUT CONTROL TABLE.
  
  WRITE ALL ITEMS TO THE DATABASE WITH A FREQUENCY OF NONE
     FOR ALL APPLICABLE ENTITIES
  
  WRITE NSOL ITEMS TO THE DATABASE WITH A FREQUENCY OF ALL
     FOR ALL APPLICABLE ENTITIES
  
  WRITE RSOL ITEMS TO THE DATABASE WITH A FREQUENCY OF ALL
     FOR ALL APPLICABLE ENTITIES
  
  WRITE STRS ITEMS TO THE DATABASE WITH A FREQUENCY OF ALL
     FOR ALL APPLICABLE ENTITIES
  
  WRITE EPEL ITEMS TO THE DATABASE WITH A FREQUENCY OF ALL
     FOR ALL APPLICABLE ENTITIES
  
  WRITE EPPL ITEMS TO THE DATABASE WITH A FREQUENCY OF ALL
     FOR ALL APPLICABLE ENTITIES
  
  NONLINEAR STABILIZATION CONTROL:
  KEY=OFF
  
  *GET ANSINTER_ FROM ACTI ITEM=INT        VALUE= 0.00000000
  
  *IF ANSINTER_                         ( =   0.00000     ) NE
        0                                 ( =   0.00000     ) THEN
  
  *ENDIF
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =       7.531   TIME= 112:51
  The automatic domain decomposition logic has selected the MESH domain
  decomposition method with 2 processes per solution.
  
  ***** ANSYS SOLVE    COMMAND *****
  
  *** WARNING ***                         CP =       7.875   TIME= 112:51
  Element shape checking is currently inactive. Issue SHPP,ON or
  SHPP,WARN to reactivate, if desired.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =       8.375   TIME= 112:52
  The model data was checked and warning messages were found.
  Please review output or errors file ( F:SDWORKSPACEMINI-PROJECT
  ANSYS WORKANSYS WORK (05-04-2020)SOIL-PILE MODEL TRIAL 1SOIL MODEL
  WITH MANUAL CONTACTS 30-04-2020600mm
  DIAMETER_ProjectScratchScrF9B3file0.err ) for these warning
  messages.
  
  *** SELECTION OF ELEMENT TECHNOLOGIES FOR APPLICABLE ELEMENTS ***
        --- GIVE SUGGESTIONS AND RESET THE KEY OPTIONS ---
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    1 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    2 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    3 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    4 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    5 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    6 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    7 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    8 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE    9 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   10 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   11 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   12 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   13 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   14 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   15 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   16 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   17 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   18 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   19 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   20 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   21 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   22 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   23 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   24 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   25 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   26 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   27 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   28 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   29 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   30 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   31 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   32 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   33 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   34 IS SOLID187. IT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH FULLY INCOMPRESSIBLE
  HYPERELASTIC MATERIALS. NO SUGGESTION IS AVAILABLE AND NO RESETTING IS NEEDED.
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   35 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   36 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   37 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   38 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   39 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  ELEMENT TYPE   40 IS SOLID186. KEYOPT(2)=0 IS SUGGESTED AND HAS BEEN RESET.
  KEYOPT(1-12)=    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0    0
  
  *** ANSYS - ENGINEERING ANALYSIS SYSTEM RELEASE Release 19.2     19.2     ***
  DISTRIBUTED ANSYS Mechanical Enterprise
  
  00000000 VERSION=WINDOWS x64   112:52 APR 30, 2020 CP=      8.516
  
  TRIAL-1(600mm dia)--Static Structural (B5)
  
                         S O L U T I O N   O P T I O N S
  
     PROBLEM DIMENSIONALITY. . . . . . . . . . . . .3-D
     DEGREES OF FREEDOM. . . . . . UX   UY   UZ
     ANALYSIS TYPE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .STATIC (STEADY-STATE)
     OFFSET TEMPERATURE FROM ABSOLUTE ZERO . . . . . 273.15
     NONLINEAR GEOMETRIC EFFECTS . . . . . . . . . .ON
     EQUATION SOLVER OPTION. . . . . . . . . . . . .SPARSE
     PLASTIC MATERIAL PROPERTIES INCLUDED. . . . . .YES
     NEWTON-RAPHSON OPTION . . . . . . . . . . . . .PROGRAM CHOSEN
     GLOBALLY ASSEMBLED MATRIX . . . . . . . . . . .SYMMETRIC
  
  *** WARNING ***                         CP =       9.578   TIME= 112:53
  Material number 55 (used by element 749703) should normally have at
  least one MP or one TB type command associated with it. Output of
  energy by material may not be available.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =       9.719   TIME= 112:53
  The step data was checked and warning messages were found.
  Please review output or errors file ( F:SDWORKSPACEMINI-PROJECT
  ANSYS WORKANSYS WORK (05-04-2020)SOIL-PILE MODEL TRIAL 1SOIL MODEL
  WITH MANUAL CONTACTS 30-04-2020600mm
  DIAMETER_ProjectScratchScrF9B3file0.err ) for these warning
  messages.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =       9.719   TIME= 112:53
  This nonlinear analysis defaults to using the full Newton-Raphson
  solution procedure. This can be modified using the NROPT command.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =       9.719   TIME= 112:53
  The conditions for direct assembly have been met. No .emat or .erot
  files will be produced.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      18.500   TIME= 113:02
  The initial memory allocation (-m) has been exceeded.
  Supplemental memory allocations are being used.
  
  Memory resident data base increased from      1024 MB to      2048 MB.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      33.484   TIME= 113:17
  Symmetric Deformable- deformable contact pair identified by real
  constant set 41 and contact element type 41 has been set up. The
  companion pair has real constant set ID 42. Both pairs should have
  the same behavior.
  ANSYS will keep the current pair and deactivate its companion pair,
  resulting in asymmetric contact.
  Contact algorithm: Augmented Lagrange method
  Contact detection at: Gauss integration point
  Contact stiffness factor FKN                  1.0000
  The resulting initial contact stiffness      0.44683E+10
  Default penetration tolerance factor FTOLN   0.10000
  The resulting penetration tolerance          0.37662E-02
  Max. initial friction coefficient MU         0.20000
  Default tangent stiffness factor FKT          1.0000
  Default elastic slip factor SLTOL            0.10000E-01
  The resulting elastic slip tolerance         0.67866E-03
  Update contact stiffness at each iteration
  Default Max. friction stress TAUMAX          0.10000E+21
  Average contact surface length               0.67866E-01
  Average contact pair depth                   0.37662E-01
  Default pinball region factor PINB            2.0000
  The resulting pinball region                 0.75324E-01
  Auto contact offset used to close gap         0.0000
  Initial penetration is excluded.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      33.484   TIME= 113:17
  Max. Initial penetration 1.331797793E-03 was detected between contact
  element 209964 and target element 216792.
  You may move entire target surface by : x= -1.327201114E-03, y=
  1.807172058E-18, z= 1.10555704E-04,to reduce initial penetration.
  ****************************************
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      33.484   TIME= 113:17
  Symmetric Deformable- deformable contact pair identified by real
  constant set 42 and contact element type 41 has been set up. The
  companion pair has real constant set ID 41. Both pairs should have
  the same behavior.
  ANSYS will deactivate the current pair and keep its companion pair,
  resulting in asymmetric contact.
  Contact algorithm: Augmented Lagrange method
  Contact detection at: Gauss integration point
  Contact stiffness factor FKN                  1.0000
  The resulting initial contact stiffness      0.44683E+10
  Default penetration tolerance factor FTOLN   0.10000
  The resulting penetration tolerance          0.33540E-01
  Max. initial friction coefficient MU         0.20000
  Default tangent stiffness factor FKT          1.0000
  Default elastic slip factor SLTOL            0.10000E-01
  The resulting elastic slip tolerance         0.35908E-02
  Update contact stiffness at each iteration
  Default Max. friction stress TAUMAX          0.10000E+21
  Average contact surface length               0.35908
  Average contact pair depth                   0.33540
  Default pinball region factor PINB            2.0000
  The resulting pinball region                 0.67081
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      33.484   TIME= 113:17
  One of the contact searching regions contains at least 768 target
  elements. You may reduce the pinball radius.
  Auto contact offset used to close gap         0.0000
  Initial penetration is excluded.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      33.484   TIME= 113:17
  Max. Initial penetration 1.218320269E-03 was detected between contact
  element 214856 and target element 206549.
  You may move entire target surface by : x= -1.016706124E-03, y=
  -3.564265712E-20, z= -6.712770927E-04,to reduce initial penetration.
  ****************************************
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      33.484   TIME= 113:17
  Symmetric Deformable- deformable contact pair identified by real
  constant set 43 and contact element type 43 has been set up. The
  companion pair has real constant set ID 44. Both pairs should have
  the same behavior.
  ANSYS will keep the current pair and deactivate its companion pair,
  resulting in asymmetric contact.
  Small sliding logic is assumed
  Contact algorithm: Augmented Lagrange method
  Contact detection at: Gauss integration point
  Contact stiffness factor FKN                  1.0000
  The resulting initial contact stiffness      0.39111E+10
  Default penetration tolerance factor FTOLN   0.10000
  The resulting penetration tolerance          0.40909E-01
  Default opening contact stiffness OPSF will be used.
  Default tangent stiffness factor FKT          1.0000
  Default elastic slip factor SLTOL            0.50000E-02
  The resulting elastic slip tolerance         0.20307E-02
  Update contact stiffness at each iteration
  Default Max. friction stress TAUMAX          0.10000E+21
  Average contact surface length               0.40615
  Average contact pair depth                   0.40909
  Default pinball region factor PINB           0.50000
  The resulting pinball region                 0.20455
  Initial penetration/gap is excluded.
  Bonded contact (always) is defined.
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      33.484   TIME= 113:17
  Max. Initial penetration 1.776356839E-15 was detected between contact
  element 218125 and target element 218239.
  ****************************************
  
  *** NOTE ***                            CP =      33.484   TIME= 113:17
  Symmetric Deformable- deformable contact pair identified by real
  constant set 44 and contact element type 43 has been set up. The
  companion pair has real constant set ID 43. Both pairs should have
  the same behavior.
  ANSYS will deactivate the current pair and keep its companion pair,
  resulting in asymmetric contact.
  Small sliding logic is assumed
  Contact algorithm: Augmented Lagrange method
  Contact detection at: Gauss integration point
  Contact stiffness factor FKN                  1.0000
  The resulting initial contact stiffness      0.39111E+10
  Default penetration tolerance factor FTOLN   0.10000
  The resulting penetration tolerance          0.40909E-01
  Default opening contact stiffness OPSF will be used.
  Default tangent stiffness factor FKT          1.0000
  Default elastic slip factor SLTOL            0.50000E-02
  The resulting elastic slip tolerance      &n