Photonics

Photonics

Topics related to Lumerical and more.

Why is the FDTD solusion of the microdisk resonator not converged?

    • XiaJi
      Subscriber

      I used the example from https://support.lumerical.com/hc/en-us/articles/360042088353. in my model, the size and material of disk are changed, and the operating wavelength of dimple is moved to 1500nm-1600n. All other settings are the same as the example, we have tried many times but I cannot get the solution. when the solution is running, the autoshutoff level did not degrade linearly to zero and it fluctuated from 0.7-0.4. Please use the file below to help check, thanks. looking forwards your reply.

    • Guilin Sun
      Ansys Employee
      This could be due to several different causes. One is the device performance its self. For example, the device has high Q resonance, which will need much longer simulation time. You can use a point time monitor and then check its spectrum to know this. If long simulation time does not resolve this, you may also reduce the autoshutoff min. In general, you may need to increase the simulation time, and reduce the autshotoff min (you can check the log file and the transmission curve (if it is smooth) to determine if it is necessary).
      The second cause might be due to the PML settings. If you kept the original override mesh with 10nm mesh size, it can be too fine for longer wavelength. I would suggest to disable the override mesh first, and see if the mesh accuracy 2 can resolve the disk well, eg, more than 10 meshes on each axis. You may need to change mesh size. When operating at longer wavelength and finer mesh size, the PML performance may be degraded as it depends on the thickness for the given parameters to absorb light striking on it. So you may 1) increase the number of layers; 2) increase the FDTD spans to make the PML away from the disk, such as half wavelength.
      You may also need to change the PML type from the current "uniaxial anisotropic" to "stretched coordinate" PML, then choose "Standard", or "Steep Angle" depending on the disk interaction with light. If light radiates from the disk at near glazing angle, the "Steep Angle" PML may be used.

      Please try those methods and see if it works for you.

    • XiaJi
      Subscriber
      many thanks for your help, please see the log contents below, we have change several settings, but cannot resolve them.

      number of processors is 4
      processors are distributed as: 2x2x1
      Running 2D Simulation
      Starting meshing
      Simulation size in gridpoints: 171 x 171 x 1
      Refined 230 mesh cells (0.786567%)
      Completed meshing!
      Meshing complete in 0 seconds of CPU time
      Starting meshing
      Simulation size in gridpoints: 171 x 171 x 1
      Refined 230 mesh cells (0.786567%)
      Completed meshing!
      Meshing complete in 0 seconds of CPU time
      finished material properties
      Selected kernel with optimization level: 2 and split-field propagation direction: 0
      -----------------------------------------
      Beginning initialization of 2D FDTD Simulation
      Including TE Simulation
      Starting to add sources to simulation

      Adding dipole source
      Adding dipole source
      Adding dipole source
      Adding dipole source
      Starting to add boundary conditions to simulation
      Adding PML BC
      Adding parallel BC
      Adding PML BC
      Adding parallel BC
      Starting to add monitors to Simulation
      Adding analysis monitor
      Adding frequency monitor
      Adding frequency monitor
      Adding time monitor
      Finished initialization of 2D Simulation
      -----------------------------------------
      All processes are communicating and ready to proceed to simulation...
      Starting 490350 total iterations
      0% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 60 secs. Auto Shutoff: 1
      1% complete. Max time remaining: 4 mins, 17 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.680187
      2% complete. Max time remaining: 3 mins, 47 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.717108
      5% complete. Max time remaining: 2 mins, 43 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.594182
      5% complete. Max time remaining: 2 mins, 35 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.667119
      6% complete. Max time remaining: 2 mins, 29 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.55346
      7% complete. Max time remaining: 2 mins, 22 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.702363
      9% complete. Max time remaining: 2 mins, 10 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.580757
      10% complete. Max time remaining: 2 mins, 1 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.698509
      12% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 54 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.613076
      14% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 57 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.632172
      15% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 54 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.581801
      16% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 48 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.633133
      18% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 44 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.618996
      20% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 39 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.652962
      21% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 35 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.570505
      23% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 32 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.598836
      25% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 28 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.665252
      26% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 26 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.558706
      28% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 23 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.622354
      30% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 22 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.586379
      30% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 20 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.595074
      32% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 19 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.581171
      33% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 19 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.698187
      34% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 18 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.700284
      35% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 17 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.671393
      35% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 16 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.665563
      36% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 15 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.523175
      38% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 13 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.589918
      40% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 11 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.644462
      41% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 11 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.591402
      41% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 11 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.613122
      42% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 10 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.592692
      43% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 9 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.63814
      45% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 7 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.622791
      46% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 5 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.594216
      47% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 4 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.630353
      49% complete. Max time remaining: 1 min, 2 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.651082
      51% complete. Max time remaining: 60 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.537526
      51% complete. Max time remaining: 58 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.580277
      53% complete. Max time remaining: 56 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.583417
      55% complete. Max time remaining: 55 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.610679
      56% complete. Max time remaining: 54 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.652343
      57% complete. Max time remaining: 52 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.654488
      59% complete. Max time remaining: 50 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.593748
      60% complete. Max time remaining: 49 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.596322
      61% complete. Max time remaining: 46 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.585222
      63% complete. Max time remaining: 44 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.631147
      65% complete. Max time remaining: 42 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.56314
      66% complete. Max time remaining: 42 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.559213
      66% complete. Max time remaining: 41 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.537773
      67% complete. Max time remaining: 40 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.626042
      69% complete. Max time remaining: 37 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.523291
      71% complete. Max time remaining: 35 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.565509
      72% complete. Max time remaining: 33 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.575397
      74% complete. Max time remaining: 31 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.562628
      76% complete. Max time remaining: 29 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.618122
      77% complete. Max time remaining: 27 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.602597
      79% complete. Max time remaining: 25 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.524987
      81% complete. Max time remaining: 23 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.576407
      82% complete. Max time remaining: 21 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.531143
      83% complete. Max time remaining: 20 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.639518
      85% complete. Max time remaining: 18 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.606287
      86% complete. Max time remaining: 16 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.534688
      88% complete. Max time remaining: 14 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.57409
      90% complete. Max time remaining: 12 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.583377
      91% complete. Max time remaining: 10 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.619757
      93% complete. Max time remaining: 8 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.485043
      94% complete. Max time remaining: 7 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.569016
      95% complete. Max time remaining: 6 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.529833
      96% complete. Max time remaining: 5 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.578902
      97% complete. Max time remaining: 3 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.537238
      99% complete. Max time remaining: 1 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.592508
      100% complete. Max time remaining: 0 secs. Auto Shutoff: 0.617288
      Completed 490350 iterations, or 5.000002e-011s of Simulation Time
      Process 0 starting to collect data
      collecting TE monitor data
      collecting TE source data
      Finished collecting data
      Simulation completed successfully at: Thu Jul 22 14:02:55 2021
      Overall wall time measurements in seconds:
      time to mesh and initialize: 0
      time to run FDTD simulation: 118
      time to finalize data and save to files: 1
      FDTD solver speed: 121.511 Mnodes/s
      total FDTD solver speed on 4 processes: 486.045 Mnodes/s

    • XiaJi
      Subscriber
      (1) I mesh with a large size(disable the mesh and choose the accuracy 2); (2) in the boundary conditions the type has been changed as stretched coordinate PML, and tried both steep angle and standard types, also increase the layers to 64; (3) the auto shutoff min has been reduced to 1e-9. but it cannot be resolved after all these done.
    • Guilin Sun
      Ansys Employee
      It seems you have used Metal BCs or Periodic BCs. Please make sure you are using PML, and PML is far away from the disk, at least half wavelength. If problem still exists, please post some structure settings and Boundary conditions here.
Viewing 4 reply threads
  • The topic ‘Why is the FDTD solusion of the microdisk resonator not converged?’ is closed to new replies.